Categories
Uncategorized

Oped: Blaming Russia for everything stops Ukraine asking what went wrong at home – Ukrainian Forum

Anna Ivanova, a Kharkiv native who works at Justus Liebig University Giessen in Germany, set out the case in an essay in the first issue of the new academic journal, themed “Has Anything Gone Wrong in Ukraine?” and published on November 3.

Intellinews.com

It is a rare challenge from inside Ukraine’s academic community to the near-consensus in Ukrainian and Western scholarship that the war, and most of the country’s problems, can be explained by Russian imperialism. Corruption at the top of government is put down to a Soviet legacy, criticism of domestic policy is dismissed as a Kremlin narrative and Russian-speaking Ukrainians are cast as victims of Russification.

Cause it’s easier to point fingers, than take real responsibility.

“This argument is much more theologically than scholarly grounded – not because it is always false, but because questioning it is often treated less as an intellectual disagreement than as an act of heresy,” Ivanova wrote. Treating Ukraine as a sovereign state means holding it responsible for its own choices, she argued: explaining all its difficulties through the Kremlin’s actions portrays it as “an object of geopolitical competition rather than a subject of its own history”.

Poorer than at independence

Ukraine entered independence with a developed industrial base, vast farmland and a population of 52mn, yet even before the 2022 invasion it was one of the poorest countries in Europe, with GDP per capita of $4,775 in 2021, according to the World Bank. Unlike most former Soviet republics, it had not restored its economy to its 1990 size by 2021. Industry’s share of gross value added fell from 54.6% in 1991 to 23.2% in 2021, as aircraft building, power engineering and the space industry disappeared and the economy came to rest on raw materials exports and cheap labour.

Not to the mention Ukraine’s infamous corruption.

The World Bank estimates that 41.6% of Ukrainians lived below the national subsistence line in 2025, roughly double the 2021 rate. Successive governments put national identity, language and memory at the top of the agenda all the same, while voters put living standards first. In a 2001 survey by the Kyiv International Institute of Sociology (KIIS), 76% named the standard of living as a concern, against about 5% for the status of the Russian and Ukrainian languages.

From exclusion to erasure

After the 2014 Euromaidan revolution the state turned its memory and language laws into instruments for deciding who belongs to the nation. In November 2016 only 35% of Ukrainians backed renaming towns and streets under the 2015 decommunisation laws and 57% opposed it, with support at 63% in the west and 18% in the east, according to Rating Group. Ukraine criminalised communist symbols, with sentences of up to five years, just as most of its neighbours were moving to administrative fines.

Prosecutions under Article 436-1 of the criminal code jumped after the full-scale invasion, from 334 cases and 24 convictions in 2015-2021 to 896 cases and 307 convictions between 2022 and mid-2025, according to historian Georgiy Kasianov. Of the 279 convictions where courts recorded social status, 124 were of unemployed or informally employed people, 84 of pensioners and 23 of people with disabilities. The offences included a hoodie bearing “USSR” and, in at least 21 cases, liking someone else’s social media post.

Language policy follows the same line. In 1991-94, 56.2% of Ukrainians named Russian as their most comfortable language, and in 2023 about 80% of residents of Odesa and Kharkiv still spoke it at home. The Constitutional Court declared Ukrainian “the code of the nation” in July 2021 and rejected the idea that Russian speakers form a distinct group needing protection.

Fear in the faculty

Violent mobilisation, draft evasion, illegal border crossings, political imprisonment and language conflicts all go largely unresearched because studying them is politically risky, and survey respondents increasingly refuse to answer sensitive questions. Ukraine has been struggling to mobilise its men for years.

“Academic disagreements are transformed into campaigns of denunciation, public shaming, and demands for ideological conformity,” Ivanova wrote. “Knowledge production is subject to police-style surveillance, the borders of which are defined by political loyalty.” She does not know, she added, whether writing the essay has already made her a criminal under laws the Council of Europe’s Venice Commission described as vague.

And this is the freedom and democracy NATO nations are supporting. It’s absurd!

Leave a Reply